This story is part of the series:
It was Monday, mid-morning. I had headed down to the woodworking store to get some new bits for my CNC router.
On my way out of the parking lot I realized I was low on fuel in the Jeep I had driven this morning. I pulled into the Mobil station.
I started the pump, but it seemed to be filling extra slow today. I leaned back against the fender and waited for it.
On the opposite side of the pump was a newer Toyota Corolla with an SDSU sticker on the back. There were two giggling girls with it. One was manning the pump while the other was bent over, cleaning trash out of the car. She was wearing a black tank top and short white shorts, the bottom of her butt cheeks clearly visible beneath the hem. I couldn't help myself from staring. "Damn what a nice ass!" I thought to myself. She then stood up and turned, and I realized that she was way too young to be dressed like that in public. She caught my look and smiled. She flipped her blonde hair and then bent over again. I knew I shouldn't stare but she was like a siren calling me towards a rocky coast. I swear as she was bent over she wiggled her ass, but it was likely just my imagination.
I checked the fuel pump and estimated my tank was only 3/4 full. I unconsciously was drawn back to looking at the girl. She stood up again and looked directly at me. I was definitely caught staring.
She giggled and said something to the other girl who was mostly hidden by the pump.
Their voices raised and I heard "Where?" and then a response of "Right there, on the other side!"
The girl behind the pump leaned back and looked at me. She had angular freckled cheekbones, full lips, and dark brown hair shoved in a ponytail through a navy blue ball cap.
There was more whispering and I hurried to just finish pumping. I didn't need a full tank, I just needed to get out of there before I was confronted for lecherously staring.
I expeditiously put the fuel pump handle back in the pump. "Dammit, stop asking questions fuel pump, no I don't need a damn receipt." I cursed to myself.
As I finally reached for my door handle, I heard "Sir, excuse me... sir."
I turned back, it was the older girl who had been pumping. Now I could see her better. She was wearing blue jean cutoffs that did a better job of covering her behind, but not by much. She had curvaceous thick thighs. A white crop shirt showed off a belly button ring but hid an apparently large set of boobs.
She looked cautiously from side to side as if to make sure nobody was listening. Well, at least apparently she wasn't going to make a scene.
"My sister said you were checking her out? Do you like young girls or something?". She looked me dead in the eye. She probably could see the guilt on my face. I was about to deny it -- which of course would have been dishonest -- when she continued. "Give me your phone."
I opened the door to the Jeep. As I did, my mind was racing. Was this a setup? No, it couldn't be right? Those girls were already at the pump when I pulled up. Were they playing me with the intention of embarrassing me? It seemed unlikely as it happened so quickly they couldn't have planned anything.
I grabbed the prepaid from the cupholder in the center console.
She seemed to sense my hesitation. "Don't worry, I just figured we could chat."
She apparently she sent herself a text message from my phone as I heard a bell sound from her back pocket. She then handed the phone back to me and return to her car. I heard the younger girl ask "What was that about?" to which she responded "Oh, probably nothing."
Whatever she was up to, she apparently wasn't sharing it with the other girl.
When I got home, I pulled Katie and Reagan aside and told them about the encounter. Katie just kissed me and smiled, "Don't overthink it. Just text her and see where it goes. If it goes weird just throw away the phone and it 'never happened.'"
"Katie is right, just think of all the incredible Tuesday playmates you would have missed out on if you over analyzed them all. You know you have a rock solid alibi with us if anyone ever asked questions." Reagan assured me.
My wives were so much more confident than I was.
I took a deep breath and unlocked the prepaid. I open the messages app and saw the message she had sent herself. It was simply a smiley emoji. But below it was another message ... she had apparently responded to it about 20 minutes ago. It said "Can you chat?"
I took a deep breath and responded. "Sure"
A few seconds later another message "I mean on the phone?"
"Sure" I responded.
"I will call you in a few."
About five minutes later the phone rang. I answered.
"Hi, this is Taylor -- the girl from the gas station. Sorry, I had to go someplace private so it took me a few minutes to call."
I told her my name and assured that the delay was fine.
"Sooo... Chloe, my sister, said you were checking her out. Was that true? Before you answer, just be honest with me."
"I will admit that I did look. Her shorts were a bit teasing and I couldn't help but look."
"But you kept looking afterwards, do you know how old she is? She is barely a teenager!"
"Do you like that? Please tell me you like that! Have you done it before you pervert? Have you put your dick up in a young girl before? I bet you have. I want to watch you put it inside my sister -- whatever hole you want -- and then if you do I will let you put it in me."
As she breathlessly blurted out all that... my brain struggled to keep up. Had she just accused me of being a pervert who likes teen girls? Or had she just offered to let me fuck a teen girl?
She clarified it all for me. "My sister is just here for the week. I take her back home to Scottsdale on Sunday so this is a limited time offer."
As my brain processed all of thos in seeming slow motion, my phone vibrated. She had apparently sent me a text with an address.
"That is my apartment address. You decide. You are welcome anytime night or day. But I need to go before my sister comes looking for me. Bye!" and just like that she hung up.
Tomorrow was Tuesday, I had been planning to go visit Mounika, Priya, and Shana. Should I go there a little late? Or should I just forget about this Taylor girl and her sister with the nice little ass? I remembered Katie and Reagan's advice to not over analyze things.
When the morning arrived, Katie woke me up we'll before dawn. "Hurry love, if are going to do what we discussed last night, you need to get going." We briefly got caught up in each other with heavy kissing. "Just go, naughty. Have fun. I love you."
I leaned over and kissed Reagan who was still sleeping before giving Katie several more kisses.
I then headed out in the damp dark air. The marine layer hung thick this morning. I looked at the clock on the dash. It was only 4:00am.
I made good time heading to the address that Taylor had sent me. There was no traffic the entire way there and I made it in just about 15 minutes.
I found the apartment building in the back corner of a seemingly brand new complex. Even with the housing crisis here in California, there seemed to be a lot of empty units as the parking lot was quite empty. I made my way upstairs to the unit in the eerie quiet. I suddenly saw a flaw in my plan, how would I get into the apartment? She wouldn't have left the door unlocked would she? I tested the handle and to my surprise it opened. I stepped carefully and quietly inside. A nightlight in the kitchenette was all that illuminated the studio apartment. I slipped out of my shoes and felt the coolness of the modern tile that covered the floor. The apartment still smelled of fresh paint. I heard movement from the opposite side of the divider wall and saw Taylor step sleepily but cautiously around.
"Thank God it is you" she whispered, pulling me to the living area. "I totally didn't think that part through. I realized it in the middle of the night and unlocked the door. I have been too scared to sleep since."
She paused before asking. "I noticed yesterday that you are wearing a wedding band. How did you sneak out on your wife so early?"
"No sneaking, she knows." I answered quietly.
"Perfect!"
She pulled me close. I felt her hard nipples poking me through the oversized t-shirt she wore as a nightgown. "Chloe is asleep. I think you figured out by now, I want to watch you rape her. I am the first resident in the building so you don't have to worry about neighbors hearing. Any way you want! The nastier you are with her, the more I will reward you."
I felt her hand at my belt buckle. She began unfastening it and quietly dropped my shorts to the floor. She then reached into my boxers and grasped my thick shaft as I pulled my t-shirt off.
"Oh, damn. Maybe you haven't fucked a young girl before -- this thing feels huge. I mean I haven't ever felt one before but this feels enormous."
I whispered in her ear, "Are you a virgin?"
"Well maybe, but my brain isn't. I will do absolutely anything for you. But only if you make it worth my while." she said, as she let go of my cock.
I quietly stepped around the divider wall as Taylor followed.
A bit of the light from the parking lot lights leaked through the blinds. It was enough for me to make out Chloe laying on her side. She was sleeping heavily. Her mouth partly open and snoring steadily.
She was wearing an oversized t-shirt too. I cautiously lifted it to find a dark colored thong below it. I gently cupped her left ass cheek in my hand. It was soft and supple. This was part of the problem that had gotten me in this situation.
I hooked my fingers in the thin wasteband of Chloe's panties and slowly pulled downwards. She stirred slightly as the panties got caught on her bent knees and I paused. She continued snoring and I carefully continued as Taylor leaned against the wall next to the bed watching me.
I gently took hold of both her ass cheeks and separated them. In the sliver of light, I could see her tight hole was inviting but I moved to the other side to take a look at her young pussy. Regrettably, it was in the shadows. I carefully reached between her legs and felt some soft pubes covering the area. I gently slid my fingers between her young lips. Unfortunately she was dry and tight. I slid off the bed and approached Taylor.
"If you want to watch me fuck her ass hole, you are going to need to get me lubricated." I whispered.
"Okay, just a little bit. Don't take advantage of the situation."
She took me in her hands and guided me to her mouth. She looked up at me as she took me deep into her mouth and slowly sucked. "Holy ..." I gasped. None of my playmates could give me head nearly as good as Katie or Reagan. But Taylor was definitely vying for a top three position.
Unfortunately just as soon as it had started it came to an end.
"That was world class!" I whispered.
She acted like she wanted to say something, but instead she just nodded.
I deliberately climbed back into the bed. I carefully pushed Chloe over onto her stomach. She didn't wake from her deep sleep.
I separated her ass cheeks again. I lined my hard cock, now moistened with Taylor's saliva, up against her tight little star.
I pushed against it and I heard Taylor whisper to herself. "Oh fuck, he really is doing it!!!"
My head slowly pushed into Chloe's little ass. The rim of the head had barely made it inside when she woke with a start.
She looked around confused. "Owww what the hell. Oh my God, get off me."
But of course I did no such thing, instead I slowly pushed deeper.
"What is happening! Stop! Don't do this." she said in panicked tones.
Taylor turned on a bedside lamp and watched.
Chloe looked over her shoulder a d apparently recognized me from the gas station. "How did you even know where I live? You fucking pervert. I am not even old enough to have sex."
I was now completely buried to the balls in her tight ass.
She began to protest even louder. "Taylor why are you just standing there. Make him stop!"
I shoved my hand over her mouth as I began to pummel her very tight ass. Tears poured from her eyes and she screamed uselessly into my hand.
Taylor sat on the bed. She was still dressed in her oversized t-shirt. She watched approvingly as my thick cock ravaged her little sister's ass.
"He knows where you live, because I invited him here." Taylor said calmly. "And no you you are not old enough for sex, but you went out of your way to tease him. So now here you are getting your little ass fucked by a huge cock!"
I thrust deep into Chloe's tight little hole. I knew it was likely painful to her, but my animal instincts had taken over and I didn't seem to care.
Chloe tossed her head, breaking free from the grasp I had over her mouth. "I am telling mom!" she yelled before I shoved her face into the pillow.
"Chloe, seriously? You think you can just go tell mom? Then what? You got raped by some guy, you don't know his name, or anything? Good luck with that. And you are so mad about it you would get me in trouble too? Also, you know mom is a total uptight prude and was pissed at the outfit you were wearing yesterday when we left the house. Do you think mom will approve of her little girl intentionally shaking her ass at a man that is mom's age?" Taylor said, beating down Chloe's confidence.
Taylor turned to me. "Don't worry, this was my idea. I won't let you get in trouble for it. Just keep up what you are doing. Fuck her little nasty ass! I will reward you." she encouraged as she watched as my thick shaft buried itself deep in her sister's little butt.
Chloe's tightness and the thrill of the situation proved to be too much of a combination for me. I grasped her little hips firmly as I felt my cum erupting from my balls. I grunted as I roughly thrust with force in her over and over. She yelped as she felt my cum spurt deep in her ass. The wetness of my cum caused obscene suction sounds as I pulled out. My cock needed a good cleanup.
I rolled Chloe over. She looked up at me with utter fear from her tear streaked face.
Her long t-shirt was turned up and I could now see her young pussy. Or rather, I could see the lips of it hiding amongst a thicket of curly blonde pubic hair.
I straddled her, my cock inches from her face. Cum was still oozing from the tip. "Go ahead! Clean it up!" I ordered.
"That was in my butt! I am not putting it in my mouth! That is just disgusting." Chloe protested.
I rubbed the messy shaft against her face. She protested "Stop!" and turned her face to avoid it but instead mistakenly dragged her half open mouth against it. She froze, her tongue was touching the shaft. She could clearly taste her own ass. She didn't close her mouth and so I gently slid back and forth. Her tongue didn't retract but instead let my cock run lengthwise against it. Then her tongue extended -- she was voluntarily doing this?! Her young hand suddenly wrapped around my shaft and she guided the whole thing into her mouth.
"Damn girl! There ya go! Suck that cock clean you nasty girl." Taylor exclaimed.
Her mouth was stretched wide around me. I may have just came but she was keeping me hard. Her blowjob skills weren't that great but the kinkiness of the situation made up for it.
Perhaps sensing I was enjoying it, Chloe stopped sucking and pushed me out of her mouth.
"There! Are you happy? I can't believe you made me do that. Now leave me alone!" she snapped.
I moved back off from straddling her chest and I think she thought I was done. Instead, I pulled her t-shirt up. Underneath was a set of B cups with pink, coat button-sized areolas and stiff nipples. I leaned forward and sucked on one.
"Please ... stop..." she uttered, but with hardly any conviction. I knew her body was telling her mind to shut the hell up.
I positioned my still stiff cock amongst the thick mass of blonde pubic hair.
"Wasn't my butt enough? Now you are going to rape my pussy too??"
I didn't answer. Instead I pushed my cock through the thick growth and in between her labia.
"Girl, you need a wax job!" Taylor mocked.
Chloe looked ashamed.
I pushed forward and found that unlike earlier she was now very wet. "Don't listen to Taylor, while waxed pussies are nice, there is nothing wrong with your bush!"
"Please don't do this to me. I am sorry for teasing you. I just liked showing off, it doesn't mean I wanted to have sex." she begged.
I pushed my cock's head in. She was tight and steamy inside. She didn't physically resist as I slowly stretched her out.
I glanced over a Taylor. She was watching intently. Her nipples were about tearing through the t-shirt she had worn to bed. That t-shirt was stretched over a very large set of boobs. She seemed very engrossed in my every move but somehow was refraining from touching herself.
I was now fully inside Chloe.
"Please don't! I promise I won't say anything, ever. Just stop!" she tried to reason with me.
But there was no reasoning with my dick. I began to shove my manhood in and out of her. With each stroke I shoved harder and deeper.
"Damn! Yes, rape her!" Taylor exclaimed loudly. She clearly was enjoying the sight of me abusing her little sister.
Tears were running down Chloe's cheeks but she didn't resist. I was thrusting hard, and she kept wincing in discomfort as my thickness stretched her wide. I felt arms wrap around me and then she looked in my eyes. The fear was gone. The distrust was gone. Instead I saw submission.
I thrust as hard as I could. She moaned loudly... not a moan of pain, but a moan of pleasure. I felt a flood of wetness all over me and realized she had orgasmed.
I kept thrusting until I too came. Her eyes filled with fear, not of me though. "Oh my God, you not only raped me you came in me? Mom is going to kill me!" she cried as spurt after spurt emptied in her.
"Seriously, you came in her? Nice!" Taylor said.
"Don't worry, I had a vasectomy so I can't accidentally get a girl pregnant." I explained.
"Well that's no fun" Taylor lamented.
Chloe asked "Are you sure?" to which I answered affirmatively.
My cock was well spent, quickly had lost most of its swelling, and I knew it would be at least an hour before it was ready to go again.
I stood up and pulled Chloe with me. I pulled her shirt completely off. I then pushed her to her knees right in front of Taylor.
"Open your mouth!" I ordered.
She obeyed, likely thinking I was going to have her suck my dick. Instead, I unleashed a stream of warm piss right into her open mouth.
"Drink it up!" I demanded. To my surprise, she did not balk at the request. Instead she closed her mouth around my cock and attempted to swallow it all. It was too much though and the piss spilled from her lips, drenching her tits, running down over her body and splattering on the clean floor.
"Oh my... " Taylor gasped as she squirmed. I realized that she must be having all she could do not to touch herself.
I finished pissing and pulled my cock out.
Chloe stood up unsteadily, likely feeling pain in both her holes. She went into the bathroom and I heard her brushing her teeth.
Taylor got paper towels and cleaned up the puddle on the floor.
Chloe emerged from the bathroom. She had wiped down her body. She approached me and kissed me.
"He raped you and you are kissing him? Did you get turned on by it? Or by the fact he is older?". Taylor asked.
"Because he is older. I don't like the rape, but I will submit to him. So if he wants to force me than I guess he will force me. I will say nothing." Chloe admitted.
Taylor turned to me. "Ok, I told you the nastier you were with her, the more I would reward you. You knocked nastiness out of the park. So what would you like?"
"Simple, every Tuesday my wives let me fuck whoever I want. I alternate through pussies. I am going to add you to the list."
"Woah woah, first what do you mean by wives?"
I explained my situation to her and she listened with shock.
"Second, uhhh... who said I would let you fuck me more than once?" she teased.
"Easy, you told me you are a virgin. Being you are very attractive and have your own apartment, if you were going to fuck around you would have already. Nothing would be holding you back."
"You think I am very attractive?" she questioned.
I approached her, and pulled her close. She threw her arms around my neck. I slid my hands under her t-shirt and held her waist. She looked up at me with her green eyes and smiled. She pulled herself closer and kissed me. Our tongues flicked and danced as we made out. Chloe sat on the edge of the bed and just watched.
I carefully pulled her oversized t-shirt over her head. I was greeted by a set of very firm DDD's. Her nipples were very erect.
"I know they look like implants, but they are all natural." she assured me. "I take after my mom. If you think mine are big, hers are enormous." Taylor said.
"Yeah but mom's are saggy. Not firm like those! I unfortunately apparently take after my ass hole dad's side of the family. Just plain average boobs." Chloe complained.
"You are still young, maybe yours will get bigger." Taylor tried to reassure here.
"Whatever, you had D cups at my age."
I continued to admire them. They were stunning. I then slipped my hands down and squeezed Taylor's curvy ass. My fingertips brushed against her panties and found them to be dripping wet.
Taylor blushed with a bit of embarrassment. "I am sorry, I came three times while watching you. I am a squirter so I made a mess."
"But I never saw you masturbating?" Chloe asked.
"I don't need to. I orgasm when I am really horny, without ever laying a finger on myself." she answered.
"Damn!" was all could say.
I slipped my hand down the front of her panties. She was soaking wet, and unlike her sister's little jungle, completely devoid of hair.
I slipped a finger between her lips and slowly pushed deep. My cock was stiffening again. It didn't matter that I had came twice in Chloe already. This girl was simply hot.
Taylor pushed me towards the bed. I fell backwards. She shimmied out of her panties. She knelt at the edge of the bed and took my cock into her mouth. Just like she had in the darkness this morning, she worked magic on it.
Chloe teased "You know that was up in my ass and pussy, right?"
Taylor shrugged. She didn't care. She continued to suck and lick on it, she was driving me absolutely crazy.
She then removed me from her sweet mouth and leaned forward pressing my cock between her enormous tits. She squeezed them together and began to gyrate up and down. She had the sexiest smile on her face as she watched me while I titty fucked her. Precum spurted from the tip, making it slippery. I would have let her continue but she stopped abruptly. She climbed up on top of me and slid me inside of her. While the first inch or of her wet virgin vagina accepted me easily, it suddenly tightened beyond that, gripping the majority of my shaft extremely tightly.
Taylor slowly gyrated her hips on me as she leaned forward, her huge tits pressed against me.
We kissed passionately. Finally she broke free to catch her breath. "I hope you don't have regrets about anything that we did today." she whispered in my ear. "Don't worry, she won't say anything."
Chloe apparently overheard the whisper. "I promise I won't. I was mad at you at first, but I am not anymore. But if we ever fuck again, you have to be rough with me just like you were today. I don't want this sweet kissy kissy stuff you two are doing."
"Oh, I don't have to be kissy kissy. I can just ride him if that makes you happier." she said, sitting up. And ride she did. She began slamming down on me as she bounced. Her huge tits bounced rigidly up and down. Her tight, barely legal pussy was squeezing my manhood firmly. Taylor moaned loudly as she rode. I watched her sexy body moving and couldn't handle a second more of it. I exploded deep in her.
"Oh my, oh, ohhh, ohh, ohhhhheeeeeooooooh" she yowled. She arched her back and she squirted, just like she had warned she would. It sprayed all over my chest and actually splattered on my face. I felt her pussy contract several times in a row and she squirted just as forcefully again. Her face flushed with embarrassment.
"Mmmmm that was amazing." I said, fully satisfied.
I laid there for a bit but I soon had to go. I had plans for the day and couldn't let other people down just because I had found a fun new playmate or two.
Chloe begged for me to visit again before the weekend when she would return to Arizona. I explained to her that my wife only allowed me to go play on Tuesday's.
Taylor reminded her that she would be visiting again in less than two months.
"Yes, but mom is coming with me then so no fun!" Chloe complained.
"We will figure it out! In the meantime, I will make sure his dick gets a good workout on a regular basis." Taylor teased.
I was rather enjoying this new playmate.